ARHS under investigation by Trump Administration’s Dept of Ed

Superintendent "appreciates the opportunity to provide a complete factual record surrounding the allegations"

As I reported earlier this week, Algonquin Regional High School is in the national spotlight after Southborough parents publicly claimed that Algonquin staff secretly counseled their child to transition genders from a girl to a boy. Yesterday, the federal Dept of Education issued the announcement, “Trump Administration Investigates Massachusetts School District for Allegedly ‘Transitioning’ Student Without Parents’ Knowledge”.

A story by the Boston Herald quotes a response from NSBORO Superintendent Gregory Martineau.

The US Dept of Ed’s announcement includes:

These allegations raise serious questions regarding whether the school district complied with federal laws protecting parents’ rights. FERPA requires schools to allow parents to access their children’s education records, make changes to those records, and provide a hearing if the school rejects the changes. PPRA requires schools to receive written consent from parents if they plan to conduct any evaluation, survey, or analysis on students regarding their or their family’s mental health, sex behaviors and attitudes, religious beliefs or any other invasive sensitive subjects outlined in the statute. It is currently unclear whether the school and the district complied with these federal statutes, and SPPO will investigate to determine whether there has been a violation under FERPA and/or PPRA.

“Parents have a right to know what is happening with their children at school, particularly when it concerns deeply personal matters involving their health and well-being,” said Frank Miller, Director of the Student Privacy Policy Office. “These egregious allegations are not an isolated problem. Families deserve answers and SPPO will thoroughly investigate reports like this and hold any educational institution that violates federal law accountable.”

The Boston Herald’s story states:

The school district says it’s aware of the federal probe, releasing a statement Thursday saying it “welcomes and will cooperate fully with any authority investigating this matter.”

“The Northborough-Southborough Regional School District is aware of the announcement by the U.S. Department of Education. It welcomes and will cooperate fully with any authority investigating this matter and appreciates the opportunity to provide a complete factual record surrounding the allegations referenced in media interviews by two individuals whose child formerly attended Algonquin Regional High School,” said Superintendent Gregory Martineau.

“The District has already unequivocally denied the referenced allegations and stands by the statement and the actions of educators and administrators,” he said.

As I previously reported, the school hasn’t responded to my question about the district’s policy or guidance they follow when a teen asks to keep parents in the dark on their request to be identified by a different gender. But a report by WBUR yesterday stated that keeping that confidential is legal in Massachusetts and linked to a document by the Mass Dept of Education that includes the following guidance on “Gender Transition”:

Some transgender and gender nonconforming students are not openly so at home for reasons such as safety concerns or lack of acceptance. School personnel should speak with the student first before discussing a student’s gender nonconformity or transgender status with the student’s parent or guardian. For the same reasons, school personnel should discuss with the student how the school should refer to the student, e.g., appropriate pronoun use, in written communication to the student’s parent or guardian.

The WBUR story also highlighted that confidentiality from parents by another school were supported by federal courts.

As I previously posted, the parents’ story made national headlines based not only on their accusations about the school’s role in the child’s transition, but also legal battle to stop DCF (Dept of Children & Families) from medically transitioning their 17 year old to a different gender. The parents also publicly claimed their child is being kept from them based on their religious beliefs.

The family’s story has been complicated as records show that DCF took the child into custody based on reports of physical abuse and subsequent court orders and restraining orders received by the teen.

Despite acknowledging in a podcast interview that there were claims of abuse, attorney Vernadette Broyles, (president and general counsel of the Child and Parental Rights Campaign) claimed that an ARHS counselor:

reported this family to DCF, we understand because they knew this Catholic family would not affirm the falsehood that their daughter was a boy

The story by WBUR provides more details on the father’s arrest for allegedly punching the child (who was 15 at the time), pulling their hair, and making physical threats. The article also included the police report on the case of the mother for alleged witness intimidation. You can read that story, which links to the police reports here.

Broyles publicly characterizes the charges against parents Joseph and Arlene Kutzko as having found by the juvenile court to be unfounded. She stated that the couple only agreed to a pretrial probation due to the high legal costs they had incurred.

DCF isn’t publicly commenting on that or the case specifics and some court details are sealed due to the involvement of a minor. But WBUR writes of the agreement reached with the parents:

a judge committed to dismissing the charges against Joseph Kutzko if he met certain conditions, including taking an anger management class, staying away from his child and abiding by a restraining order. Arlene Kutzko also agreed to stay away from the victim and abide by a restraining order. The conditions for both parents remain in place until this December.

Subscribe
Notify of
4 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Karen Hanlon Shimkus
2 months ago

Beth, this is a bit of spin. You forgot to mention the most important primary question of whether or not this is crazy government overreach to actively plan to administer potent drugs to a minor — acting as the parent and in lieu of a parent — without the legal guardian / parent’s knowledge or consent. That’s the real question at hand.
What government thinks it has the right to do that? And act in secret?? It would be more helpful to keep that the focus. Thanks

Jim Foley
2 months ago

Karen Hanson Shimkus
I couldn’t agree more with you.

Karen Hanlon Shimkus
5 days ago
Reply to  Jim Foley

Thanks Jim. Dear Readers and Beth:
Please see the following YouTube video, a NEWSMAX interview, important comments below the video itself, and legal decision information by DCF below on the Kutzko – Algonquin H.S. – Dept. of Children & Families matter, per public sources.  
PARENTS, VERY IMPORTANT TO LISTEN TO THE ENTIRE INTERVIEW.  PER THE INTERVIEW WITH NEWSMAX, ALLEGATIONS OF ABUSE WERE CONCLUDED BY DCF AS “UNFOUNDED” WITHIN TWO WEEKS of the claims.   Their poised and articulate Harvard educated attorney also offers spot on commentary.
 To all those who participated in this national embarrassment, shame on you.  The policy of secrecy has been addressed by the Supreme Court per information below (Mirabelli v. Bonta). 
 YOUTUBE LINK, INTERVIEW WITH NEWSMAX (hit control, click to open link):  
 She Went to School and NEVER Came Home: A Family’s Battle with Massachusetts DCF
2608255
Per public sources: Regarding allegations of “abuse” the DCF conclusion is reported as “unsupported.”  See below. Also, public sources cite a “lack of evidence” on allegation of “neglect.” 
“The Massachusetts Department of Children and Families (DCF) concluded that the abuse allegations against the Kutzko parents were “unsupported,” but they determined that the parents were guilty of neglect. This led to the removal of their child from the home.
nbcboston.com wcvb.com
 DCF’s Conclusion on Alleged Abuse, Overview of Findings
The Massachusetts Department of Children and Families (DCF) investigated allegations of abuse against Joseph and Arlene Kutzko, the parents of a 17-year-old girl. The DCF’s findings were as follows:
· Abuse Allegations: The DCF concluded that the allegations of physical and sexual abuse against the Kutzko parents were “unsupported.”
· Neglect Determination: Despite the lack of evidence for abuse, DCF determined* that the Kutzko parents were guilty of neglect. This conclusion was significant enough to lead to the removal of their child from the home.” (*not a court of law)
U.S. Supreme Court, Overview of Findings
Also, importantly, the U.S. Supreme Court has concluded that parents may sue for being kept in the dark. See below, Mirabelli v. Bonta case.
 “The U. S. Supreme Court (Mirabelli) ruled 6-3 that California’s secret gender transition policies in schools violate parents’ constitutional rights, restoring a PERMANENT INJUNCTION PROTECTING PARENTAL AUTHORITY. The decision signals that STATE POLICIES CANNOT OVERRIDE PARENTAL AUTHORITY . . .This landmark ruling is considered one of the most significant parental rights decisions in recent decades, reshaping the legal landscape for parental involvement in the education and child-rearing decisions nationwide. . .”  thomasmoresociety.org.”
 Thank you.  

Karen Hanlon Shimkus
14 minutes ago
Reply to  Jim Foley

PS — Update: Jim and Readers — see this week’s Boston Herald, link below. The Kutzko family will be testifying on Capital Hill in early December.  
This week the Boston Herald reports on the ongoing, nearly two-year Massachusetts custody battle involving Joseph and Arlene Kutzko, who lost custody of their teenage daughter in December 2024 following a dispute over her gender transition and have since faced a permanent restraining order. The parents describe the severe emotional and physical toll the separation has taken on their household, noting that stress-related health crises have led to hospitalizations for both of them.
For the full story, please see the following links:
VERY IMPORTANT Boston Herald ARTICLE 11-17-26
https://www.arcamax.com/currentnews/newsheadlines/s-4346621
SOUTHBOROUGH: A mother facing a criminal charge for saying she misses her daughter
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8IqgypDhLBA&t=24s
Also, importantly, please see the 4.12 mark in the YouTube video where the mother describes an Algonquin High School staff member asking her to TAKE DOWN THE CATHOLIC CRUCIFIX in HER OWN HOME.  Are we still living in the United States of America??  
Also, this STAY-AT-HOME mom is currently right now being targeted to be arraigned by Waltham Court for speaking to the press. This stupid and misdirected lawfare is an attempt to get her arrested, in order to trigger more criminal charges with more crazy consequences to ensure that mom (or any family member) gets any opportunity to speak to their minor child and work it out via family therapy no matter what the situation is. 
Arresting a STAY AT HOME MOM ??  REALLY ??? Who is stating to the press that she misses her minor child ??? This is moronic, biased, harmful lawfare. This is an absolute waste of judicial resources and crazily frivolous lawsuit, a serious misuse of the justice system. To all involved in this debacle, this continues to be a ridiculous national embarrassment.  
To all parents, please see the very important comments under the YouTube video.   Stay informed. This could be you and your family.  Thank you.  

  • © 2026 MySouthborough.com — All rights reserved.