Two-Family Zoning Update

Clarifying current zoning restrictions and an update on ZBA's plan after the failed vote

I’m following up on an inaccurate statement made at the recent Special Town Meeting about what’s allowed under current zoning bylaws for two-family homes.

And, I’m updating readers on the Zoning Board of Appeals’ decision of how to handle the defeat of their proposed bylaw change.

Last week, I promised readers that I would follow up with the Building Commissioner on an assertion that was made at the October 17th Special Town Meeting.

During the debate on Town Meeting floor many commenters worried about the impact of removing a 2 year time restriction for applying to convert single family homes to a two-family home. Some argued that it would lead to the tear down of modestly priced housing to be replaced with new, more expensive duplexes.

Affordable Housing Trust member Ellen Marya told voters that the current bylaw already allows for the change. She argued:

There is nothing in our bylaw now that says someone cannot buy a house that has been in existence for two years and tear it down and turn it into a two-family house. This is not a two-year waiting period on ownership. It’s a two-year waiting period on how long the building has been in existence. That is currently allowed, and that is not what we have seen in town.

Nobody rebutted her statement in the meeting.

When I covered the story last Tuesday, I noted that the current bylaw restriction is on the “conversion” of single family homes to two-family homes. I was surprised to hear that could cover building a new two-family home after tearing down an old home.

I wasn’t sure that was accurate, so reached out to the Building Commissioner. Since he was unavailable, I promised readers I would follow up.

Yesterday, I was able to confirm my reading of the bylaw with Building Commissioner Mark Robidoux (who is the Town’s Zoning Enforcement officer). According to him, the tear down and new build wouldn’t be covered as a conversion.

As for the ZBA’s plans. . .

At last week’s ZBA meeting, the board and their administrator discussed whether or not to revisit the zoning bylaw at a future Town Meeting. They decided to wait, based on the belief that the state will be passing related zoning changes.

As I’ve previously covered, state legislators have been working on changes that would limit Town’s abilities to to restrict two-family/multi-family housing. But the legislature’s house and senate have been hashing out very different bills. They have yet to settle on a version that both agree on. 

ZBA members and their administrator appeared to assume the legislature will succeed at passing something. Once the state passes a change that the Town needs to address, the ZBA will propose a bylaw revision to Town Meeting.

In the ZBA’s recap of Town Meeting’s reaction to their zoning change, they appeared to misunderstand some of the criticism. (That may be related to their having interpreted the bylaws the same way that Marya had.)

Members referred to John Butler as having accused the board of changing the zoning without holding public forums on the change. What Butler accused the board of was not accurately communicating to the public what the change represented.

He said that what the ZBA described as simply removing a time restriction was actually their opening up a new use that didn’t previously exist in Southborough — the ability to apply to build new condos in any residential neighborhood.

During the Special Town Meeting, developer Jack Bartolini pointed out that, in a way, the option does already exist. But the method he outlined is a slow one with risks.

Bartolini described having built small single family units on Flagg Road. Two years later, he added on the other half of what are now duplexes.

A developer who followed in Bartolini’s footsteps could be thwarted if upset neighbors lobby the ZBA to deny a special permit for the second half of a duplex/townhouse.

Subscribe
Notify of
1 Comment
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
John Butler
18 days ago

The ZBA is right to wait and see what emerges from the State. If new legislation passes in the next year or two, enacting local zoning now is premature, as our bylaw would likely require immediate revision. However, if state action stalls beyond that time, we should be prepared to broaden permissions for duplexes ourselves.
The key challenge is in implementation. The ZBA’s initial proposal to simply remove existing barriers was shortsighted and potentially damaging, as was discussed at Town Meeting. The Planning Board should investigate how we can do this in a prudent way, one that avoids the risk of this step making our Town even less affordable.
First, the town should eliminate the 7% cap on over-55 condo developments—a straightforward step that is long overdue. While the ZBA cited senior downsizing to justify its proposed duplex changes at Town Meeting, their proposal, incomprehensibly, left this cap intact, proposing to create a direct contradiction within our zoning code. Removing the cap is a necessary first step.
Beyond lifting the over-55 cap, loosening restrictions on two-unit condos must be done carefully to avoid incentivizing teardowns—a problem that has already severely disrupted towns to our east. Contrary to popular belief, new duplexes are not inherently affordable; roughly 35% of our current housing stock is valued below our median duplex condo price, and new condo duplexes will command significantly higher prices.
Without thoughtful guardrails, teardowns of modest ranch and Cape homes, replacing them with visually incompatible duplexes, will actually decrease overall affordability in Town. This risk is especially acute in Residential B zones, where the profit margins on a new duplex can justify a teardown even when a single-family “McMansion” would not be viable.
Rather than simply stripping protections—such as the “timing clause” the ZBA sought to remove—we should consider allowing new construction duplexes but using precise zoning techniques such as Floor Area Ratios (FAR). This approach could potentially allow more duplex development on vacant lots while capping scale to protect older, lower-priced housing stock. If the State does act, we need to see if we can comply with whatever law it passes while blunting its threat to the portion of our housing base that is lower priced than new condo duplexes will be. We need to be prepared in this way, either to act on our own or to respond to State action.

  • © 2026 MySouthborough.com — All rights reserved.